
Baseball, warmer weather – some good things are happening. Thanks for stopping by. Your tips and comments are welcome. You can follow me through the week on the twitters. Here we go.
Please consider making a contribution to The Public’s Radio during our spring pledge drive.
*** want to get my column in your inbox every Friday? Just sign up right here ***
1) There’s a huge delta between the best-case and worst-case scenarios for Rhode Island’s healthcare landscape. If a big out-of-state firm swallowed a major RI hospital group, more care would likely migrate elsewhere, with negative implications for RI’s economy. On the other hand, the academic health system envisioned by Lifespan and Care New England, with Brown University, could bolster economic growth and have other benefits. Still, there are a lot of unanswered questions, including whether this unified entity would cause higher healthcare costs for average Rhode Islanders. Brown University President Christina Paxson doesn’t believe that will happen, in part, she said, since RI is so small and since greater scale is needed to generate efficiency. “You can’t provide effective low-cost care with this sub-scale healthcare system — it doesn’t work,” Paxson said on Political Roundtable this week. “So I’m excited about this, because I think we’re going to be able to provide better care to patients. I think it can be, bend that cost curve, keep costs from going up.” The agreement announced in February between Brown, Lifespan and CNE still faces a series of regulatory hurdles. And there’s the matter of how RI’s two biggest hospital groups will resolve questions of governance and overcome the institutional politics that have scuttled this kind of amalgam for years. Asked to outline the process for working this out, Paxson sidestepped the question, saying, “My sense now is that the two healthcare systems, and again I don’t sit in those boardrooms. But my sense is that they are in a very, very different place than they’ve ever been before. And the Coronavirus, the COVID pandemic, taught them, really underscored how they can work together well. They can collaborate, and that coming together, you know, put the governance battles aside …. And I really hope it works.”
2) On her way out of Rhode Island, Gina Raimondo released a 34-page report on her six years as governor. She claimed credit for making the Ocean State more equitable and strengthening its economy. RI did make some gains on its business tax climate during Raimondo’s time in office, climbing in the Tax Foundation’s survey from 45 to 37. But Rhode Island still faces many of the same familiar economic challenges that existed before Raimondo became governor, including under-performing schools, the absence of a more diverse job base, and projected deficits of more than $300 million for each of the next four fiscal years. As I reported this week, Raimondo put considerable focus on trying to foster high-wage jobs, although RI was one of just two Northeast states to lose so-called advanced sector jobs from 2015 to 2019.
3) Gov. Dan McKee plans sign the Act on Climate, billed by supporters as the most important environmental bill to emerge from the General Assembly in years, in Newport on Saturday. The legislation requires RI to get to net zero climate emissions by 2050. Supporters, such as Sen. Dawn Euer (D-Newport), say it will boost the economy and help to create green jobs. Opponents say they still fear that the climate bill will spark big retrofit costs for consumers and give too much power to unelected state bureaucrats. Meanwhile, the legislation got an assist from Attorney General Peter Neronha, who moved quickly to dismiss McKee’s concern that the bill could cause excessive litigation.
4) A 2017 study that examined 38 universities, including Brown, found that they were more likely to admit students from the top one percent of income strata than the bottom 60 percent. So, are colleges like Brown perpetuating the power elite by not taking more aggressive steps to counter this imbalance? I put that question to Christina Paxson on Political Roundtable.
Here’s her response: “College access in America is a major issue. And we need to get more students from lower- and middle-income backgrounds into higher education. And when I say that, I’m not talking about privates, like Brown. I’m talking about the vast majority of students in America — college students are at public institutions. And I’m a big advocate for public education, too — that needs to be supported as well. So you know, what are we doing? We are need-blind; there are not many universities in the country that accept students regardless of their financial need. When we admit students, we meet their full need, which means you know, we don’t say, great, we’d love to have you, but we can’t afford to give you the scholarship that you need to come. Three years ago, we eliminated loans from financial aid packages. So those were all converted to grants. We’ve seen steady improvement in the breadth of students who are coming to the university. It’s in the high 40 percent received financial aid. And we’ll continue to make progress on that. It’s a really important issue.”
5) An important update from my colleague Lynn Arditi: the emergency medical dispatch training program at RI’s 911 Emergency Center, which was supposed to be up and running this month, will probably not launch until fall or winter.
6) Rhode Island’s familiar economic challenges notwithstanding, Gina Raimondo is now among the women who run the U.S. economy, as Reuters noted this week: “This sea change may already be affecting economic policy – a new $2.3 trillion spending plan introduced by Biden last week includes $400 billion to fund the ‘care economy,’ supporting home- and community-based jobs taking care of kids and seniors, work normally done by women that has mostly gone unacknowledged in years past.” And Raimondo continues to be a media fixture, as seen by how she took part in a White House briefing this week with press secretary Jen Psaski. Raimondo talked up President’s jobs plan, the need to invest in broadband and semiconductors, and took questions from reporters.
Here’s one exchange, from a White House transcript, on Biden’s ambitious infrastructure plan.
Q How many Republicans have you had face-to-face conversations with?
SECRETARY RAIMONDO: If you include Zoom as face-to-face —
Q Yes.
SECRETARY RAIMONDO: — I would say very many. Only a few actually face-to-face, but a lot. You know, a lot. And I plan to do even more of it. Like, we’re serious about this. We want to get this done. There’s a lot of different ways to do it. The President does what a leader does: puts forth his ideas. Now let’s get to work. Let’s talk about it. Where do we tweak it? Where do we change it? …..
I can tell you this: Every single business leader I’ve talked to applauds the fact that this package is more than just roads, bridges, and water. Like, come on, 35 percent of Americans in rural areas don’t have broadband. You cannot have a modern economy without that. We have a crisis in semiconductor manufacturing. You cannot have a modern economy without that.
7) Dan McGowan has grown up before our eyes, starting as a freelancer at RI’s Future and the Providence Phoenix, gaining experience at GoLocalProv, polishing his chops at WPRI, and spearheading The Boston Globe’s expansion into Rhode Island. Now, in a smart move, the Globe has made McGowan a columnist, helping to fill the void in the opinion space of Rhode Island’s mediascape. How did we get here? A short recap: The Providence Journal laid off metro columnist Bob Kerr years ago, it eliminated the political columnist post where M. Charles Bakst long wielded a strong moral voice, and the ProJo eliminated about a year ago the house editorials that used to drive statewide debate. Some might say opinion is devalued in an age when everyone with a computer can rant on Facebook. There’s a big difference, though, when informed opinion is based on fact. With a persona that is part old school reporter and part pro wrestling/chocolate cake enthusiast, McGowan has the capability to walk the line between editorializing and delivering straight news – a trick not really done hereabouts since the death in 2015 of Jim Baron of the Times of Pawtucket. Gannett, which owns the ProJo and a host of other papers in the region, has a business model based on collecting a lot of eyeballs through its various properties. That leaves a local news opening in some places – and McGowan’s new role shows how the Globe is aggressively pressing to increase its mind share in Rhode Island.
7B) I’ve got so many column ideas for Dan. Remember when he almost lost his lunch while trying to catch up with Jorge Elorza during one of the Providence mayor’s community runs through Roger Williams Park? Dan testing his questionable athleticism against the gubernatorial field for 2022, with different sports, could be a fun read.
8) The decennial process of redrawing legislative and congressional districts is getting under way, with House Speaker Joe Shekarchi’s introduction of a bill this week to create an 18-member special commission. Two-thirds of the slots are reserved for lawmakers, reflecting the controlling stake that legislative leaders have over a process that has traditionally rewarded friends and punished enemies. During the White House briefing this week, Commerce Secretary Raimondo – whose agency includes the Census Bureau – said redistricting data is expected no later than September 30. John Marion from Common Cause of RI parsed the RI House bill; he reports that lawmakers are optimistic that the Ocean State will be able to maintain two congressional seats (!). Time will tell.
9) The ProJo’s Alex Kuffner reported this week on how National Grid is making millions through an electricity bill surcharge related to the first in the nation Block Island wind farm. The Deepwater Wind project has long faced questions about cost and who’s benefiting, so this debate will likely continue.
10) RI poli-media people on the move: Pete Gaynor, who went from Providence EMA director to state EMA director to eventually lead FEMA under President Trump, and also serve as acting director of Homeland Security, is returning to Rhode Island for his new gig: leading a new consulting practice for resilience, response and recovery program for LiRO Engineers, part of GISI …. Josh Block, formerly comms director for Gov. Raimondo, has signed on in the same role with the Shah Foundation, which, he said, “does innovative, community-oriented work on issues ranging from food insecurity, to health care, to equity in education.” ….. Finally, big congrats to Phil Eil, who has inked a book deal with Steerforth Press to tell the story of a doctor serving four consecutive life sentences for prescription drug-dealing activity in Ohio from 2003-06. Phil has been pursuing this project for years, as all of us acquainted with him know, so this is an important milestone. I had the good fortune of meeting Phil when he pitched me as a freelancer at The Providence Phoenix. Although I was skeptical about his first concept — about famous/overlooked people who are buried in RI – he won me over and became a steady contributor. Phil went on to succeed my successor at the Phoenix, David Scharfenberg (now at the Boston Globe), as the last news editor of the alt-weekly, before it closed in 2014. He’s a fine fellow and an excellent writer, so I’m very much looking forwarding to reading Phil’s book and seeing what he does next.
11) With the Biden infrastructure plan offering a potential windfall for states to use in re=imagining their transit systems, I asked Scott Wolf of Grow Smart RI to share thoughts on what he would like to see happen. Wolf said the state is well positioned to compete for discretionary federal grants and infrastructure stimulus thanks to the completion of the long-range Transit Master Plan. (“the controversial RIDOT-led multi-hub proposal for downtown Providence was neither conceived nor vetted as part of the RIPTA-led transit master planning process,” he added. “Advocates continue to call on the governor to withdraw that proposal and explore transit-friendly alternatives.”)
Here’s Wolf’s wish-list for the potential use of transit in RI: “Today, 77 percent of Rhode Islanders live within a 10-minute walk of a transit stop, yet less than 3 percent commute by transit. Building a system that gets more people where they’re going more quickly and efficiently holds great potential to reduce transportation emissions while saving Rhode Islanders money. Among the transit initiatives we hope the state will consider prioritizing with new federal transit funding are additional Bus Rapid Transit routes like the popular one currently in operation along Broad and North Main streets, a general increase in the frequency of RIPTA service, development of an in-state light rail line between Central Falls and Green Airport, improved, speedier commuter rail service between Providence and Boston, additional funding for bike and pedestrian infrastructure that is in greater demand than ever as a result of the public heightened appreciation for outdoor activity associated with the pandemic, and funding for more ‘Complete Streets’ projects that ensure new and repaved streets are safer and more user friendly for all users, including pedestrians, bicyclists, children, the elderly and the disabled.”
12) In assessing former Gov. Raimondo’s economic record, state Sen. Sam Bell (D-Providence) – a critic of tax incentives – said more focus should have been put on place-making and infrastructure designed to spur growth and attract people. “It’s why we moved the highway, it’s why we reopened the rivers and created WaterPlace Park,” he said. “Those real investment approaches to economic development continue to drive growth in Providence today. Yet the Raimondo administration vetoed and stopped the main effort to do a similar vision that would have unlocked an enormous amount of jobs and growth when they blocked a proposal to remove the 6/10 and unlock enormous areas of Providence for economic development.”
13) The Duck & Bunny Snuggery was one of those idiosyncratic places that are part and parcel of Providence’s identity. Last weekend, the building housing the Wickenden Street enterprise was demolished, to the surprise and disappointment of many. Ward 1 City Councilor John Goncalves lamented that advanced notice of the demolition was not communicated – or required. “The long-time owners indicated that they had hoped to rehab the property, but the building was in such poor shape it was preferable and more cost-effective to demolish and rebuild than to repair,” he said in a statement. More on the subject from David Brussat. RI Monthly has details on the planned rebuild.
14) A case study in what happens when Facebook fills a news void in a Pennsylvania town, via NBC News. Excerpt: “The News Alerts of Beaver County isn’t home base for a gun-wielding militia, and it isn’t a QAnon fever swamp. In fact, the group’s focus on timely and relevant information for a small real-world community is probably the kind that Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg envisioned when he pivoted his company toward communities in 2017. And yet, the kind of misinformation that’s traded in The News Alerts of Beaver County and thousands of other groups just like it poses a unique danger. It’s subtler and in some ways more insidious, because it’s more likely to be trusted. The misinformation — shared in good faith by neighbors, sandwiched between legitimate local happenings and overseen by a community member with no training but good intentions — is still capable of tearing a community apart.”
15) Some of the hidden history in the development of the interstate highway system.
16) URI alum John King, who cut his teeth in the Providence and Boston bureaus of The Associated Press, is set to open the inaugural lecture series honoring the late WJAR-TV investigative reporter Jim Taricani. It’s on for 5 pm on Wednesday, April 21. Via URI: “As a URI junior and Associated Press intern, King met Taricani in 1984, the same year New England organized crime boss Raymond L.S. Patriarca died and Providence Mayor Vincent ‘Buddy’ Cianci was forced to resign from office. “ ‘So much has changed in the nearly four decades since,’ said King. ‘We live, learn and work now in the Age of Disruption: breathtaking technological innovation and equally breathtaking assaults on truth, science, and common sense. But a lesson learned then is just as relevant now, perhaps more so: The First Amendment and the freedoms it protects, and the fairness and responsibilities it demands, remain a best friend and best compass in challenging times.’ ”
17) While baseball was long considered the national pastime, MLB’s decision to move the All-Star game out of Atlanta has become grist in the Red State/Blue State divide. As James Pindell notes, this is just part of wider polarization: “Americans are deeply divided over politics and there are inequalities involving race, class, and gender that shape how people live. Now on top of this, the politics of each state’s governor has direct ramifications over individual lives of residents.” Still, if some fault MLB for injecting politics into sports, they overlook how sports have always reflected politics and broader societal trends. Baseball got a laughable anti-trust exemption from the U.S. Supreme Court in 1922 that spared it from some of the conventions of capitalism. The Red Sox didn’t introduce their first Black player until a dozen years after Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier in 1947. Many minor league players receive shoddy treatment. And racism has remained in the headlines in connection with the Sox.
Ian Donnis can be reached at idonnis@ripr.org

