
With the exception of a verdict, Rhode Island’s big political trial of 2020 is in the books. We’ll break that story down in this week’s column. As always, I welcome your tips and comments, and you can follow me through the week on the twitters.
*** want to get my column in your inbox every Friday? Just sign up right here ***
1) Is Jeff Britt guilty of a felony count of money laundering? That’s the question hanging over the 52-year-old longtime political operative with the conclusion of his week-long trial in Kent County Superior Court. The picture that emerged in court was similar to what was evident earlier: some fast and loose maneuvers led to the production of the Shawna Lawton mailer endorsing House Speaker Nicholas Mattiello during the speaker’s tight 2016 re-election campaign for state rep in Cranston. Whether that’s a misdemeanor, a felony requiring a prison sentence of up to 20 years, or something else, depends on your view. Prosecutors called the mailer part of a scheme that corrupted the election process, evaded a reporting requirement, and they say Britt was at the center of all that. Some others see this as the criminalization of politics. And defense lawyer Robert Corrente pointed to what didn’t happen while the focus remained on Britt: how the state Board of Elections, for example, didn’t question the speaker or his chief of staff, Leo Skenyon, during its probe of the Lawton mailer, even though Skenyon was closely involved in the speaker’s campaign. Corrente has maintained the case is overcharged, likening it to dropping an atom bomb on a bug, and he’s arguing for the dismissal of the felony count. When it came time to testify for Skenyon and a former Mattiello staffer, Matt Jerzyk, they said they didn’t remember many of the details from the 2016 race. (Corrente displayed electronic communications showing that people in Mattiello’s circle knew about the mailer.) The verdict from Superior Court Judge Daniel Procaccini in the Britt case is expected in up to four to six weeks, a timeline that could place the decision after the November election.
2) Judge Procaccini’s decision may break new legal ground since this money laundering charge has been used rarely if ever in Rhode Island. One of the key questions is whether a statute calling for a prison sentence of up to 20 years, and a fine of up to $500,000, is appropriate for an alleged crime involving $1,000. This question seemed to be on Procaccini’s mind as he gave the prosecution and defense instruction Friday for their written arguments. The judge noted how money laundering laws in some other states have different penalties for offenses involving different amounts of money, while Rhode Island does not. He also pointed to how the RI statue involves three elements, while the prosecution indictment touched on four – a matter he called “a little confusing …. And I’m not saying this with any bad faith or any intention,” Procaccini said, “but has the language somehow, when whoever was charged with just writing the actual writing of the indictment, did it get manipulated in a fashion that the intent or application of the statute is been distorted in a way that might have some legal effect?”
3) Britt’s trial exposed the underside of campaign politics in Rhode Island. Key prosecution witness Victor Pichette, a private investigator, testified that in 2016 he surveilled Steve Frias, the GOP opponent of Speaker Nicholas Mattiello, and took pictures of guests and a visitor log at a Frias campaign event. Pichette cited an absence of business records for his PI practice, which included doing opposition research.
Testimony also pointed to the role played by Statehouse staffers in managing Mattiello’s campaign. The politicization of legislative employees is an open secret, although the speaker’s office has traditionally maintained that any political work is done voluntarily on off-work hours. Here’s reaction from John Marion, executive director of Common Cause of Rhode Island: “While it’s commonplace for senior staff to be involved in campaign work on their own time in other states, the line between the government’s time and the campaign’s time is too blurry in Rhode Island. And while the trial did not showcase lower-level employees who worked on the Mattiello re-election campaign, the power of patronage in the State House did come up. It highlighted something else unique about our legislature; everyone from the chief of staff to the doorkeeper is a political appointee.”
4) If people were expected the Britt trial to produce a bombshell for Speaker Mattiello amid his latest election challenge, this time from Republican Barbara Ann Fenton-Fung, that didn’t happen. During his somewhat brief turn on the stand, Mattiello said he was angry when he learned of the Lawton mailer, because he thought it would hurt his campaign. For now, the race between Mattiello and GOP opponent Barbara Ann Fenton-Fung is mostly a referendum on whether 1) voters in House District 15 favor a Smith Hill newcomer untainted by years of Statehouse controversies or 2) believe that the speaker has a positive track record and can do more to deliver for Cranston.
While Fenton-Fung is a fresh face, a key question is what she’d be able to get done, if elected, as part of a small GOP minority in the House. Speaking this week on Political Roundtable, Fenton-Fung said she believes she can find common ground with Democrats on some issues. “I think there’s a lot of opportunity on a bipartisan basis to get some clean government reforms done,” she said. “And I think that’s something we can do easily over the next two years.”
5) Joe Biden appears to be gaining a stronger hand in the presidential race, with less than 30 days until November 3. If President Trump’s support is fading, does that help Mattiello in his rep race with Fenton-Fung, in conservative-leaning House District 15? During Roundtable, Fenton-Fung was asked if there was anything that Trump could do or so that would lead her to not support him. “The things he says are inexcusable,” she said, referring to the Access Hollywood tape and Trump’s criticism of John McCain for being a POW. “They are disgusting, they make my toes curl.” Be that as it may, Fenton-Fung said, she believes Trump is better qualified to improve America’s economy, based on how things were going before the pandemic.
6) With the race between Mattiello and Fenton-Fung still to be decided, it remains unclear for now what will happen with the leadership of the House. Rep. Gregg Amore (D-East Providence), who contributed to 10 rep candidates in the most recent filing period, including primary winner Brandon Potter, said that’s consistent with his traditional amount of support for fellow Democrats. “Bob Craven and I are Mattiello people,” Amore said, adding that he expects Mattiello to win his rep race. But if Mattiello loses, Amore said, he expects that both Craven (D-North Kingstown) and he would pursue the speakership.
7) Erika Niedowski lived with great zest. She was enthusiastic about the good things in life – cheese, cats, hockey, laughing, wearing hoodies in cold weather and so much more. I got to know Erika when she became an AP reporter in Providence and spent a lot of time at the Statehouse. Her winning smile, great sense of humor and intellect made it fun to be around her. We’d laugh about things like the bundling of bills or the tiny Bobby Orr action figure she kept in the basement press office on Smith Hill. Joined by some other reporters, we jammed out to Ylvis’ “The Fox (what does the fox say?)” in someone’s car on a cold March day in 2014 as Nick Mattiello staged a closed caucus at the Providence Marriott, on the way to becoming speaker. As others have noted, Erika took journalism seriously, but she didn’t take herself seriously. We saw less of each other as she pursued other directions, most recently as an environmental advocate. It came as a terribly sad shock to learn that Erika died last Friday, at age 46, from an illness. My heart goes out to her partner, Patrick Laverty, and other members of her family. An environmental justice fund created in Erika’s memory has already raised more than $18,000. If you’d like to contribute, you can do so here.
8) The House Judiciary Committee’s Antitrust Subcomittee this week released its findings on tech giants and digital competition. “As they exist today, Apple, Amazon, Google, and Facebook each possess significant market power over large swaths of our economy,” Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerrold Nadler of New York and Antitrust Subcommittee Chairman David Cicilline said in a joint statement. “In recent years, each company has expanded and exploited their power of the marketplace in anti-competitive ways. Our investigation leaves no doubt that there is a clear and compelling need for Congress and the antitrust enforcement agencies to take action that restores competition, improves innovation, and safeguards our democracy. This report outlines a roadmap for achieving that goal.”
9) What are the chances? On the same day when the Judicial Nominating Commission chose finalists for the RI Supreme Court seat vacated by Gilbert Indeglia, John Howell broke the news that Francis X. Flaherty is retiring. For Gov. Gina Raimondo, this has the congenial effect of creating an opening to nominate the state’s first Black Supreme Court justice, Melissa Long, as well as outgoing RI Senate Judiciary Chairwoman Erin Lynch Prata.
10) My colleague Antonia Ayres-Brown, Newport reporter for The Public’s Radio, went to a gun-safety class at the Newport Rifle Club to examine why more Rhode Islanders, including women, are buying guns. Excerpt: “Even as initial panic around COVID-19 has subsided, monthly firearm sales in Rhode Island have remained at an unprecedented high. Small Arms Analytics & Forecasting, an independent research group, found over 35,000 guns were sold by the end of August — roughly 30 percent more than the total from all of 2019.”
11) With the Rhode Island Political Cooperative and other progressive groups basking in the glow of a series of legislative primary victories in September, the Gaspee Project isn’t ceding the battlefield. The conservative group this week announced plans to spend about $50,000 in independent expenditures ahead of November 3. Via release: “ ‘Businesses and families are fed up with both the entrenched political class and the extremist newcomers to the political scene,’ said Clay Johnson, chairman of the nonprofit organization. ‘Our supporters – the builders, the caregivers, and the professionals of Rhode Island – demand a new direction for our state.’ The expenditures (which are not coordinated with or authorized by any candidate committee) will include postcard mailers, social media, audio ads, and local print ads. Only candidates who took the Taxpayer Protection Pledge were considered for support. The theme of Gaspee’s campaign clearly contrasts Democrats, who are beholden to unruly and violent socialist ‘mobs’ … vs … Republican candidates, who support the rule-of-law and a free-market approach that creates ‘jobs.’ ”
12) Via my colleague Sofia Rudin: The Providence External Review Authority, PERA, the independent monitor of Providence police, has raised concerns about how other officers did not intervene in an alleged assault by a colleague.
13) Proposals to raise taxes on affluent Rhode Islanders are bound to get more discussion given the growing progressive caucus on Smith Hill. Critics say this will drive more people out of the Ocean State. Supporters point to how New Jersey reached deal in September for a “millionaire’s tax” and how the state hasn’t slid into the Atlantic. “[I]n this unprecedented time, when so many middle-class families and others have sacrificed so much, now is the time to ensure that the wealthiest among us are also called to sacrifice,” said NJ Gov. Philip Murphy, a former Goldman Sachs exec.
14) The campaign to pass Ballot Question 1 – which would remove “Providence Plantations” from the state name – launched this week. “For too many Rhode Islanders, the inclusion of ‘Plantations’ in our state name connotes a racist and pro-slavery past,” campaign director Erich Haslehurst said in an email. “Changing our state’s name is one step we can take, together, to address this history in our language and say once and for all that the name of our state is: Rhode Island. Period.”
15) Call it the equivalent of Speaker Mattiello disparaging Barbara Ann Fenton-Fung in a mailer as some carpetbagger from Middletown. U.S. Sen. Susan Collins, in a tough re-election fight with Sara Gideon, is pointing to how Gideon is from – gasp! – Rhode Island.

