
These days, you don’t even have to take your credit card out of your wallet in order to buy something. If you are shopping online, you can store your credit card numbers on your computer and just hit “click to pay.” In a store, call up Apple Pay or Google Pay on your smartphone and tap it against the payment terminal.
There’s a term now for this type of purchase: frictionless payments. And it might make spending money a little too easy for some people.
In a recent paper based on data from a Chinese bank, researchers found that customers charged 9.4% more on average to their credit cards, through both online and in-person transactions, after they adopted a mobile payment method than they had before.
The paper does not explore the effects frictionless payments are having on credit card debt. But the paper’s lead author, Yuqian Xu, an assistant professor at the Kenan-Flagler Business School at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, told NPR she believes they probably play a significant role.
Given the paper’s findings, and surveys showing that about half of the U.S. population uses mobile payments, Xu estimates that approximately 4.5% of total credit card usage in the country is due to the influence of frictionless payments. That means, she calculates, that about $50 billion of the $1.13 trillion in current consumer credit card debt can be attributed to the ease mobile payment apps present.
Here are other excerpts from an interview with Xu, edited for brevity and clarity.
You did this research with a Chinese bank. Would you say that the way people use mobile payments in the U.S. likely follows a pretty similar pattern?
Yes. A fundamental mechanism here is the convenience that mobile payments bring to consumers. Therefore, we would expect that the effect would be similar in the U.S. mobile payment market.
It takes about 40 seconds to buy something with a physical credit card, compared to just 30 seconds to buy it with a smartphone. Can just 10 seconds make people change their buying habits?
The main reason underlying the increase in usage is convenience. And the convenience manifests in two primary ways. This swift transaction process contributed significantly to the overall convenience experienced by users. But there’s another part of the convenience derived from the absence of the need to carry additional physical cards or a wallet.
What about yourself? Do you find yourself using your phone more often than you would a credit card?
Yes, I do find that actually. In the past, I tended to forget to bring my physical cards. And this actually sometimes created a barrier to buy things. But I don’t tend to forget my mobile phone. I bring my mobile phone every day. So I find I purchase more with mobile payments.
Do you have any tips for people who want to control their spending? Should they avoid these mobile payment apps?
I would say, don’t avoid these mobile payment apps. Technological advancements can offer us a lot of convenience and improve the security of financial transactions. What’s most important is that people need to be aware of these dynamics — we can better manage our financial resources, potentially reducing impulsive expenditures.
Transcript:
AYESHA RASCOE, HOST:
These days, you don’t even have to take your credit card out of your wallet in order to buy something. If you’re shopping online, you can store your credit card numbers on your computer and just hit click to pay. In a store, just call up Apple Pay or Google Wallet on your smartphone and tap it against the payment terminal. There’s a term now for this type of purchase – frictionless payments – and it might make spending money a little too easy for some people. Yuqian Xu, an assistant professor at the University of North Carolina’s Kenan-Flagler Business School, has been researching frictionless payments and joins us now. Welcome to the program.
YUQIAN XU: Yeah, thank you very much for your time and my pleasure to share some recent findings from my research. You and your colleagues studied what happened when a Chinese bank first made its credit cards accessible through a smartphone app. Did people spend more when they had that convenience?
XU: Yes. We find that when people actually adopt this mobile payment platform, they tend to spend more. Give you some numbers. Based on our analysis, we show that the adoption of mobile payments can increase the total credit card transaction amount and the frequency of the focal bank by 9.4% and 10.7%, respectively.
RASCOE: So people spend about 10% more money and made about 11% more transactions. There’s some research out there that says it takes about 40 seconds to pay for something with a physical credit card, compared to just 30 seconds to buy with a smartphone. Can just 10 seconds make people change their buying habits?
XU: The main reason underlying that is because of this convenience. But the convenience manifests in two primary ways. This swift transaction process contributes significantly to the overall convenience experienced by users. But there’s another part of the convenience derived from the absence of the need to carry additional physical cards or a wallet, and we believe this, brought by the advancements in technology, actually contributes to the increase of the transaction amount and frequency by users.
RASCOE: So what about yourself? Do you find yourself using your phone more often than your credit card?
XU: Yeah, I indeed find that. Actually, I also observed that for the people around me. I’ll give you an example. Ever since the cafeteria downstairs started using the mobile payment, I find that including me, many other students are also using this mobile payment to make their transactions. And for a consumer like me, I tend to forgot bring my physical cards. And this actually sometimes creates the barrier for me to pay. But with mobile payments – I don’t tend to forget my mobile phone.
RASCOE: Yeah, so, U.S. consumer debt climbed to $17.5 trillion at the end of last year, the highest since the Great Recession when you adjust for inflation. Do you think the increase in mobile payments is part of the reason why?
XU: Yes, I indeed believe that the adoption of mobile payment technology could actually be a contributing factor to the current increasing debt in the consumer consumption market. Although I want to also clarify, this is not a direct finding from this paper. But now let’s consider in the U.S. market, almost everybody now using a mobile phone and about 50% use mobile payment. Going back to our 10%, with this amount of the total credit card transaction, it can easily give us about 50 billion more consumption in the credit card.
RASCOE: Well, do you have any tips for people who want to control their spending? Should they avoid these mobile payment apps?
XU: So I would say not to avoid these mobile payment apps. We live in the area that the technology advancements actually give us a lot of convenience and improve the security. But what’s most important is people need to be aware of this change, these dynamics, why we are spending more. We can actually better manage our financial resources.
RASCOE: That’s Yuquian Xu, an assistant professor at the Kenan-Flagler Business School at UNC Chapel Hill. Thank you so much for joining us today.
XU: Yeah, thank you very much. My pleasure.


