U.S. Airman Roger Fortson answers the door of his apartment on May 3, 2024, as captured by the body camera of the Okaloosa County sheriff's deputy responding to a report of a domestic disturbance. A split second later, the deputy fired at Fortson, killing him.
U.S. Airman Roger Fortson answers the door of his apartment on May 3, 2024, as captured by the body camera of the Okaloosa County sheriff’s deputy responding to a report of a domestic disturbance. A split second later, the deputy fired at Fortson, killing him. (Okaloosa County Sheriff’s Office | Okaloosa County Sheriff’s Office)

The shootings of two men on opposite ends of the country this month have refocused attention on deadly force standards for police — and how officers should respond to the sight of a gun. In both cases, the men were fatally shot within moments, even as they held their weapons pointed down.

On May 3, “fourth-person” reports of a domestic disturbance at an apartment complex in Okaloosa County, Florida, brought a sheriff’s deputy to the front door of 23-year-old U.S. Airman Roger Fortson, who was alone in his apartment. The deputy’s body camera video shows him pausing to listen at Fortson’s closed door, then knocking, waiting, knocking and again and calling out, “Sheriff’s office, open the door!”

The door opens and Fortson comes into view: a slender African-American man dressed in jeans and standing barefoot on the tiles of his entryway. His left hand is coming up in an open-palm gesture; his right hand is holding a pistol. It’s held loosely, pointed at the floor. In the second it takes him to open the door, the deputy says, “Step back,” unholsters and draws his gun, and fatally shoots Fortson.

“It wasn’t a good exchange, he never fired a weapon or anything,” says Benjamin Crump, an attorney. who represents Fortson’s family and appeared at the funeral. “He respected authority,” he says of Fortson.

The Okaloosa Sheriff’s Office initially called the shooting “self-defense,” but the case is now under investigation by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Ten days later, another man holding a gun pointed down was shot and killed by police during a domestic disturbance call, this time in Anchorage, Alaska. The morning after the shooting, Police Chief Bianca Cross said the man, Kristopher Handy, had “raised the long gun towards officers,” but a video released later by one of Handy’s neighbors appears to contradict that. It shows Handy outside the apartment building, walking toward officers with an apparent long gun held roughly parallel with his legs. Like Fortson, Handy was shot within moments of facing the police.

The Anchorage Police Department is investigating; Handy’s family is calling for the release of body camera videos of the incident.

Kristopher Handy faces police during a domestic distburbance call in Anchorage, Alaska, moments before being shot. This image comes from a video recorded by a neighbor, who says Handy never pointed the long gun he was holding
Kristopher Handy faces police during a domestic distburbance call in Anchorage, Alaska, moments before being shot. This image comes from a video recorded by a neighbor, who says Handy never pointed the long gun he was holding (Virginia Miller | YouTube)

The recent deaths have renewed questions about whether police are allowed to shoot someone who’s armed, but not pointing the weapon.

“There is no hard and fast rule as it relates to that,” says Rodney Bryant, a 34-year veteran of the Atlanta Police Department, former chief, and now president of the National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives.

“Sometimes you may have a person that’s not pointing that still may pose a significant threat to law enforcement officers,” Bryant says. “But… you can have a very similar situation and it’s clear the person is not a threat.”

No Hard And Fast Rule

What complicates matters for police is the science of human reaction times. At Washington State University, Stephen James runs a lab that studies this by running subjects — including police officers — through simulations. Those studies have demonstrated a two-to-three-second disadvantage for officers who wait to have a weapon pointed at them.

“There’s no way a human can see the weapon coming up, make a decision about whether or not it’s a threat, then decide to press the trigger and then the electrical signal has to go from the brain down the nervous system into the finger,” James says. “If you have to wait for all of that, the other person will get a shot off first.”

Because of this lag, James says officers across the nation are trained that “action will beat reaction.”

But he says that’s not an excuse to preemptively shoot anyone holding a gun.

James also takes part in state-mandated reviews of police shootings, and he says police have to keep the law in mind, especially the 1989 U.S. Supreme Court case Graham v. Connor, requiring an officer’s decision to shoot to be judged by a “reasonableness” standard.

“When we look at the totality of the circumstances, is the individual acting in a threatening manner? Are they being compliant or are they being defiant?” Even the location of the person could end up determining whether a shooting is justified.

“[In] the case in Florida, it was within the threshold of his own home. And that is absolutely protected by the Second Amendment as long as he could legally hold the firearm,” James says. “It’s very different when you’re out in public … and we don’t allow open carry of guns in schools, for example.”

“It’s hard to train for this,” says Chief Bryant. He says he’s seen some departments that emphasize the research showing the time disadvantage for officers who wait; others emphasize the need to back up and de-escalate a potential confrontation, if there’s time.

What he has seen over three decades in policing, he says, is that officers are facing this situation more often, especially as states have legalized open carry. And it can take time for an officer to understand what’s happening.

“I’m arriving on the scene, and the person that’s taking the gun from one person — from the volatile person — is there intervening, and I pull up and they have the gun,” Bryant says. “I don’t know who’s who, but I challenge that person as well [to drop the gun],” he says.

“When you have the proliferation of weaponry that we’ve seen, you just encounter it more,” he says. “Seeing the gun will be very common, and we have to be prepared for that on both sides.”

Transcript:

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

How should police respond when they encounter someone holding a gun but not pointing it? It’s not a new question, but recently, two separate fatal shootings by police on opposite ends of the country have highlighted just how critical that split-second decision can be. NPR’s Martin Kaste reports. And a warning – this story does contain the sound of gunshots.

MARTIN KASTE, BYLINE: This question is in the news right now mainly because of the shooting in Florida of a U.S. airman named Roger Fortson back on May 3. Reports of a domestic disturbance brought an Okaloosa County sheriff’s deputy to his apartment complex, where the staff directed him to Fortson’s apartment. Fortson was home alone. His family says he’d been talking to his girlfriend on FaceTime.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED DEPUTY: Sheriff’s office – open the door.

KASTE: This is from the deputy’s body camera. If you freeze the image of Fortson opening the door, you can see a gun in his right hand held at his side, pointing down. His left hand is coming up with an open palm gesture that looks like wait. But the deputy doesn’t wait.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BENJAMIN CRUMP: They shoot six shots into his body.

KASTE: Here’s civil rights attorney Benjamin Crump, representing Fortson’s family as the case is investigated.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

CRUMP: It wasn’t a good exchange. He never fired a weapon or anything. He respected authority.

KASTE: Is there any justification for an officer to shoot someone who’s pointing a gun down? Well, there is science to consider. Steve James runs a lab at Washington State University that uses simulations to study human reaction times. He says the simple fact is that an officer who waits for a gun to be pointed is already at a disadvantage.

STEVE JAMES: There’s no way a human can see the weapon coming up, make a decision about whether or not it’s a threat, decide to press the trigger, and then the electrical signal has to go from the brain down the nervous system into the finger. If you have to wait for all of that, the other person will get a shot off first.

KASTE: Of course, you could see that as an excuse for cops to preemptively shoot anybody holding a gun. But it’s not, James says, because beyond the science, there is the law. Police are bound by court precedents that require them to be reasonable in their assessment of a situation.

RODNEY BRYANT: Everyone holding a gun isn’t a threat.

KASTE: Rodney Bryant was Atlanta’s police chief, and now he’s president of the National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives. He says there’s no simple rule here because the courts and police trainers want officers to look at the big picture.

BRYANT: You have to take into consideration the person’s demeanor, what’s going on with the person, what they’re saying, what they’re doing at the time of having that weapon.

KASTE: An example of this is the other recent police shooting of a man with a gun that was pointed down, this time in Anchorage, Alaska on May 13. Again, the police were responding to a domestic disturbance call.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Oh, my God.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR BROADCAST)

VIRGINIA MILLER: They’re calling him. They’re giving him orders to put his hands up, and they shoot him almost mid-order.

KASTE: This video comes from Virginia Miller, a neighbor in the apartment complex. Here, she describes what she saw to Alaska Public Media reporter Wesley Early.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR BROADCAST)

MILLER: At no point during this altercation did he ever lift the gun up and point it at the police.

KASTE: Superficially, it seems like a similar situation to Florida. Police shoot a man who’s holding a gun by his side pointed down. But the experts say you have to consider these other factors. The man in Alaska, Kristopher Handy, was outside his home. He just cursed at someone and was walking toward the police. Those details could end up making the difference. But Chief Bryant says other police departments do tend to watch these cases very closely.

BRYANT: Anytime you see a situation like this, the first people you are talking to is your training staff, so you continue to evaluate that level of training.

KASTE: And he says a key thing in all of this is reminding officers that they’re simply going to see more people with guns now and, quote, “we have to be prepared for that on both sides.”

Martin Kaste, NPR News.