When The Conjuring came out in 2013, “nobody could have imagined it would have the incredible life that it’s had,” said filmmaker Michael Chaves.
Chaves directed three of the nine films in the Conjuring series, including the latest, The Conjuring: Last Rites, out Sept. 5. Now it’s the most lucrative horror movie franchise in history, worth well over $2 billion, with spin-offs that include The Nun and Annabelle movies.
The heroes of The Conjuring movies are based on a real-life couple: Ed and Lorraine Warren. They were professional ghostbusters with a knack for packaging their experiences into books, TV and movie deals. The Conjuring movies all draw explicitly from the Warren’s real-life cases. (Ed Warren died in 2006, Lorraine Warren died in 2019.)
The Conjuring: Last Rites is about one such case: a family who claimed their house was haunted. In various media interviews dating from the 1980s, Jack and Janet Smurl said a demon was hurting members of their family, that included four young daughters. They said it injured the family dog and sexually assaulted at least one parent. All of this is in the movie.
“Carefully,” Chaves said when asked how he crafts horror films based on the experiences of real-life people. While making Last Rites, he said he worked closely with the Smurl sisters, now adults. “It really left big scars on their family and on them as individuals,” he said. “One of the things that really struck me was just how much the Warrens meant to them. When so many people were very skeptical about them, the Warrens came in and the Warrens believed.”
In The Conjuring movies, the Warrens are heroes. But in lively conversations on social media, many horror fans disagree.
“They have always been entertainers,” observed Grady Hendrix. A bestselling author of horror novels, Hendrix also studies the occult in popular culture. Ed and Lorraine Warren started crafting their image with public lectures in the early 1970s, he said, after the novel and the movie The Exorcist became a huge success.
“The Catholic Church had gone through [the Second Vatican Council] when it liberalized in the ’60s, and there were a lot of sort of old school Catholics — Ed was one — who felt like the church had gotten too liberal and it needed to get back to its more conservative roots,” Hendrix said.
Hendrix said the idea that Satan attacks Christians and their faith with demonic entities was enticing to some old-school believers. But the real people who became characters in The Conjuring movies suffered from terribly sad backstories that often included histories of substance abuse, other forms of abuse, generational trauma and mental health crises.
“These are cases where people are in distress, and I don’t think it helps to have a couple of people who have no training and no clinical background show up, tell you it’s a demon, and walk away with book and movie contracts,” Hendrix said.
The 2021 movie The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It was based on a real family whose preteen son saw visions, quoted from the Bible and spat at and hissed at people, according to interviews given by his parents to such outlets as The Washington Post and People magazine in 1981.
“His family had recently seen The Exorcist on TV. His sister had gone to a lecture by the Warrens beforehand,” Hendrix said. “They decided he was possessed and his older sister’s boyfriend invited the demon to come into him.”
When the boyfriend, Arne Cheyenne Johnson, later murdered his landlord, the Warrens encouraged him to plead not guilty, by reason of demonic possession. As the Post reported at the time:
“We tried to warn Arne,” sighed Lorraine Warren, clairvoyant. “But he just wouldn’t listen.”
“It’s just one of those things you never do,” says Ed Warren, demonologist. “Not if you know anything about this sort of thing.”
Soon, everyone will know about this sort of thing, what with the diligent work the Warrens are doing in spreading the word to the press. “Will we have a book written about this?” Lorraine Warren asks rhetorically. “Yes we will. Will we lecture about it? Yes, we will.” Are they talking to writers and movie producers? “No, we’re not,” she says. “Our agents at the William Morris Agency are.”
In 2010, family members sued Lorraine Warren and the writer of a book about the case after the book, The Devil In Connecticut, was re-issued. Their lawsuit, which was ultimately dismissed, claimed the family had been exploited and manipulated. Tony Spera, the Warrens’ son-in-law, told NPR the lawsuit was “very frivolous.”
Spera directs the New England Society for Psychic Research, which the Warrens started. Spera and his wife, Judy Warren, are major characters in the new movie and positioned to be central ones if the franchise continues.
“They never knew them,” Spera said of skeptics criticizing the Warrens. “They’re armchair quarterbacks. They’re trying to say that the cases were phony, they’re fraudulent, they’re not real.”
The cases are real, Spera insists. But any movie made from them is generally intended as entertainment. “It’s not meant to be a documentary,” he said. “Not meant to be a word-for-word transcribing of what happens.”
Still, when director Michael Chaves made the third Conjuring film, he questioned himself, as he told NPR.
“I really struggled with it,” he said. The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It supports the Warrens’ version of how Arne Cheyenne Johnson committed murder after becoming demonically possessed.
“I really struggled with just even the morality of that story, and, you know, we were telling the story of a murderer,” Chaves said. He acknowledged that the victim’s family now must live with the knowledge that a movie, that earned more than $200 million at the box office, argues the killer was innocent because he was under the influence of a demonic force.
As a horror writer, Grady Hendrix said he’s a sucker for a ghost story. But he’s haunted, he said, by people with untreated mental health disorders, children who may have been abused and people who self-harmed and harmed others, whose problems were solved on screen with exorcisms and whose real and painful stories are told as entertainment.
Transcript:
SCOTT DETROW, HOST:
A scary movie opening this weekend is part of a wildly successful franchise.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “THE CONJURING”)
LILI TAYLOR: (As Carolyn Perron) There’s something horrible happening in my house. Could you come take a look?
DETROW: The first film in The Conjuring series came out in 2013. It is about a haunted house. Now, the Conjuring universe is worth more than $2 billion worldwide, with nine films that include spinoffs, like one about a possessed doll named Annabelle. It is the most lucrative horror movie franchise in history, and as NPR’s Neda Ulaby tells us, the whole thing is based on a controversial real-life couple.
NEDA ULABY, BYLINE: The newest movie is called “The Conjuring: Last Rites.”
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “THE CONJURING: LAST RITES”)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (As character) The devil has come to Pennsylvania.
ULABY: It’s based on real people who believed their house was haunted.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “THE CONJURING: LAST RITES”)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #2: (As character) Jack and Janet Smurl claim that an evil presence has found its way into their home.
ULABY: In the mid-1980s, Jack and Janet Smurl told the media that a demon was abusing their family – including four young daughters – that it hurt a family pet, that it sexually assaulted them. In the movie, the family is helped by a pair of professional ghostbusters named Ed and Lorraine Warren.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “THE CONJURING: LAST RITES”)
PATRICK WILSON: (As Ed Warren) So when did this start?
ULABY: The Warrens were also real people who have since passed on. Here’s the film’s director, Michael Chaves.
MICHAEL CHAVES: Obviously in our movie, you know, the Warrens are heroes. They do their best to save the day.
ULABY: But not everyone thinks of the Warrens as heroes.
GRADY HENDRIX: They have always been entertainers.
ULABY: Grady Hendrix is a bestselling author of horror novels. He has long studied the occult in popular culture. Ed and Lorraine Warren, he says, started crafting their public image in the early 1970s, after the huge successes of “The Exorcist” novel and movie.
HENDRIX: They started saying that they were demonologists and that they were experts and that they had seen secret church files about all the exorcisms in America.
ULABY: Exorcisms – they’re a big part of The Conjuring movies.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “THE CONJURING: LAST RITES”)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #3: (As character) By the power of our Lord Jesus Christ.
HENDRIX: The Catholic Church had gone through Vatican II, when it liberalized in the ’60s. And there were a lot of sort of old-school Catholics – Ed was one – who felt like the church had gotten too liberal and it needed to get back to its more conservative roots and really embrace the idea that there is a Satan who’s attacking people.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “THE CONJURING: LAST RITES”)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #4: (As character, screaming).
ULABY: But the Conjuring movies are based on real people with terribly sad backstories, says Grady Hendrix – substance abuse, other forms of abuse, generational trauma, mental health crises.
HENDRIX: These are cases where people are in distress. And I don’t think it helps to have a couple of people who have no training and no clinical background show up, tell you it’s a demon and walk away with book and movie contracts.
ULABY: Take one case that became a book, a made-for-TV movie and the 2021 movie “The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It.”
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “THE CONJURING: THE DEVIL MADE ME DO IT”)
WILSON: (As Ed Warren) It’s July 18, 1981. This is Ed Warren, here with Lorraine.
ULABY: It’s about another real family whose preteen son saw visions of monsters, quoted from the Bible and hissed at people, according to media interviews with his parents.
HENDRIX: And his family had recently seen “The Exorcist” on TV. His sister had gone to a lecture by the Warrens beforehand. They decided he was possessed.
ULABY: And his sister’s boyfriend invited the demon to come into him. Later, Hendrix says, the boyfriend murdered his landlord and served five years in prison.
HENDRIX: But the Warrens showed up to say, no, he’s not guilty by reason of demonic possession, which the judge very rightly threw out right away.
ULABY: Eventually, two family members sued Lorraine Warren, claiming the family had been exploited and manipulated.
TONY SPERA: Which was a frivolous lawsuit, to be honest with you. It was very frivolous.
ULABY: And it was dismissed, says Tony Spera. He represents the estate of Ed and Lorraine Warren. Spera married their daughter, Judy, and now runs a society for psychic research the Warrens started. Spera says he’s used to people criticizing the movies and the Warrens.
SPERA: They never knew them. They’re armchair quarterbacks. They’re trying to say that these cases were phony, they’re fraudulent, they’re not real. It’s not meant to be a documentary. It’s not meant to be a word-for-word transcribing of what happened.
ULABY: Still, director Michael Chaves says he struggled with the ethics.
CHAVES: During “Conjuring 3,” I really struggled with it.
ULABY: Chaves directed that movie and the new one. For “The Conjuring: Last Rites,” he says he worked closely with the four now-adult sisters who were all minors when their parents said their house was haunted.
CHAVES: You know, it really left big scars on their family and on them as individuals. And I guess one of the things that really struck me was just how much the Warrens meant to them. When so many people were very skeptical, the Warrens came in and the Warrens believed.
ULABY: Chaves says he believes the Warrens, too. Grady Hendrix is not so sure.
HENDRIX: Look, I write horror for a living. I’m a sucker for a ghost story the same as anyone else.
ULABY: But Hendrix says what really haunts him are people with untreated mental health issues, children who may have been abused and people who harmed others whose problems were solved on screen with exorcisms and whose real stories were told as entertainment.
Neda Ulaby, NPR News.
