The Capitol on March 3, the day before President Trump will deliver is State of the Union address in Washington.
The Capitol on March 3, the day before President Trump will deliver is State of the Union address in Washington. (Julia Demaree Nikhinson | AP)

Four House Republicans defied their party leadership on Wednesday in an attempt to extend Affordable Care Act subsidies slated to expire at the end of the year.

Hours before the House passed a narrow GOP health care bill that would not extend the subsidies if signed into law, the quartet joined with Democrats to force leadership to schedule a vote on a three-year extension on health care insurance subsidies.

The move made by moderates from competitive districts — Representatives Rob Bresnahan Jr., Brian Fitzpatrick and Ryan Mackenzie of Pennsylvania, alongside Mike Lawler of New York — means the House is likely to vote on reviving the subsidies in early January.

Fitzpatrick and Democrat Tom Suozzi of New York co-chair the House Problem Solvers Caucus, a bipartisan group that tries to craft policy solutions and legislative agreements across party lines.

The two spoke with NPR’s Michel Martin about why House Speaker Mike Johnson resisted a vote to extend health care subsidies, how they plan to compromise on the bill with the Senate, and what they fear might happen to millions of Americans if Congress cannot find a solution on this issue.

Listen to the full interview by clicking on the blue button above.

The radio version of this story was edited by Reena Advani and produced by Luke Garrett and Paige Waterhouse. The web copy was written by Destinee Adams and edited by Obed Manuel.

Transcript:

MICHEL MARTIN, HOST:

We’re joined now by one of the four Republicans who voted for the discharge petition. That’s Congressman Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania. He is here along with Democratic Congressman Tom Suozzi of New York. They are the co-chairs of the Problem Solvers Caucus. That’s a bipartisan group that tries to craft policy solutions and legislative agreements across party lines. Thank you both so much for joining us.

TOM SUOZZI: Yeah. Good morning. Thanks for having us.

BRIAN FITZPATRICK: Thanks for having us.

MARTIN: Congressman Fitzpatrick, I’m going to start with you. You’re bucking your own party’s leadership on this. It’s not for the first time, but what brought you to this decision on this bill?

FITZPATRICK: Yeah. So Tom and I and a number of our colleagues, we’re part of a bipartisan coalition. You know, we’re trying to craft a two-party solution that would’ve, you know, kept these credits in place, particularly for people that need them the most, and also taken some steps to fix things that could use improvement in the ACA system, but not, you know, throw everything out and let it expire. Because there’s a lot of people, particularly of the lower- and middle-income earners, that really need this help. If we do nothing, these prices are going to spike, in some cases very significantly. And we have an obligation to do what we can do, you know, here in this chamber to prevent that from happening. So we try to work with leadership. We’ve been working on this for months. We couldn’t get leadership to give us a floor vote. That’s all we want, is to allow democracy to take hold on the floor of the House and let the votes fall where they may. That vote was blocked, so we took the action we did.

MARTIN: Why do you think the speaker is so resistant to having a vote even on extending the subsidies for a year, which is one of the other Republicans who signed the discharge petition, Congressman Mike Lawler of New York – was something that he proposed some time ago? Why do you think the speaker is so resistant?

FITZPATRICK: Well, I think, you know, that would be a question for him. What I suspect and what he’s shared in prior conversations, they don’t like the premium tax credit system. They think that it’s – that there’s a lot of fraud in the system. You know, there’s a lot of people that get so-called zero premiums or free health insurance on the lower-income levels, many of whom never filed a claim, which leads one to think that maybe they don’t even know they’re insured. So a lot of that money that’s going to the insurance company might be a complete windfall for the insurance company. So it’s important to note that our compromise bills, our two-party bills, address that. You know, we tackled that problem, but we still also extended the subsidies, extended the tax credits for the people that need them most. So this doesn’t need to be an all-or-nothing, zero-sum game. You know, we can come to the center and build consensus.

MARTIN: Congressman Suozzi, the Problem Solvers Caucus held a meeting with a bipartisan group of senators. The Senate failed last week to extend the credits. If this passes the House and heads to the Senate, is there a path forward there?

SUOZZI: Yeah. Let me first just start by applauding Brian and the other Republicans that joined us. It was very courageous of them to do that. It was a big step forward. Is there a path forward? Well, the senators we met with are excited about the fact that we are – have these 218 votes to move this bill forward and send it to the Senate, which will give them a vehicle by which they can debate this issue and try and bring it on the floor. It’s unlikely that they’ll actually pass this same bill. So they’re going to propose some sort of compromise, and we’ve started talking about potential compromises already.

MARTIN: Congressman Suozzi, could you give us any sense of what the conversation was like? I mean, is there a sense that more Republican senators would vote for an extension of the subsidies if the House passes this?

SUOZZI: It’s been publicly reported that there have been senators – Democrats and Republicans – who have been having conversations with each other. And a lot of things they’ve talked about are similar to the bipartisan compromises that Brian and I, along with our other colleagues, have negotiated up until this point. They’re very similar ideas. The problem is, is that we couldn’t get it to the floor in the House, and they haven’t been able to get it to the floor in the Senate. This step yesterday will help to move this whole thing forward. This is the impetus that’s needed to get a vote in the House and to send it to the Senate, where this bipartisanship and this compromise can work together.

MARTIN: Congressman Fitzpatrick, to that end, is it your sense that there are other Republicans who will vote for this once it gets a vote on the floor?

FITZPATRICK: Yes, I do. There was, in fact, a very, very large number that were interested in signing a compromise bill and voting for a compromise bill that both extended the subsidies and, you know, allowed for commonsense reforms. In terms of a clean three-year extension, I think that number is much smaller. But yes, the answer is they will. You know, I’m exhibit A of that. I don’t like the clean extension without any income cap. But given the choice between a clean three-year extension and letting them expire, that’s not a hard choice for me. And I suspect many of my other colleagues are going to view it the same way.

MARTIN: I have to ask about the politics of this. Are you concerned that, Mr. Fitzpatrick, your party will suffer if they don’t find a solution to this, if there is not a solution to this problem?

FITZPATRICK: I’m not concerned about a party suffering. I’m concerned about people suffering back home. This is a personal thing. You know, a lot of my colleagues are throwing out, you know, these numbers. It only impacts seven, 8% of the population. But for that seven or 8% of the population, this means everything to them. You know, staying up at night, not knowing how you’re going to pay your bills, particularly on something as sensitive and personal as health care, you know, that causes a lot of anxiety. It causes health problems. It’s more taxing to our system when people don’t stay up on their health until they have an emergency and they have to go in.

SUOZZI: And let’s just put it in real-life scenario. If you’re making $130,000 a year and you’re a family of four, right now, with the premium tax credits in place, you pay 8.5% of your income for your health insurance. That’s about 10 or $11,000. If these premium tax credits expire, your insurance premiums will go from 10 or $11,000 a year to $30,000 a year. When those folks decide not to buy insurance, not only will their family suffer incredibly, but it’ll reduce the size of the insurance pool, which causes everybody’s insurance to go up. This is a real-life problem that we came to Congress to try and actually solve these things.

MARTIN: So final question to you, Congressman Suozzi. When realistically could this bill go to the floor? I mean, the speaker could choose to call it sooner, but traditionally, there is a waiting period for a discharge petition. If he does adhere to the holiday recess, the bill won’t get to the floor till January. Is that what you anticipate?

SUOZZI: A lot of us are pushing for him to do this before we go home, and he could do that if he chose to do that. It would probably be smart for him to do it politically, to have a solution baked in instead of going these several weeks over the holiday season. But it must be voted on by January 6. That’s what the rules would require.

MARTIN: That is Congressman Tom Suozzi of New York. He is a Democrat. He was here with us along with Congressman Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania, who is a Republican. They’re the co-chairs of the Problem Solvers Caucus, which is, as we said, a bipartisan group that tries to craft legislative agreements across party lines. Gentlemen, thank you both so much for speaking with us.

SUOZZI: Thank you.

FITZPATRICK: Thanks so much.

(SOUNDBITE OF THE JAZZ JUNE’S “FALLING ASLEEP ON LINCOLN DRIVE”)