Updated Wednesday June 10 at 3:20 pm.

The purpose of the hearing was to give the public a chance to weigh in on the city’s proposed tax levy for the coming fiscal year. 

Over 300 people tuned in, and the hearing was beset by technical problems that delayed it by half an hour. Local activists had been planning to use the hearing as a forum to press the city to shift funding from the police department to other programs, including education, housing, and mental health services. Initially, Finance Committee Chair John Igliozzi gave speakers 3 minutes each, and warned that given the high number of people in the meeting, he might reduce each person’s time allotment. 

But the meeting ended abruptly, after just 11 members of the public spoke. 

Of the first five people, three used racist slurs including the N-word, and a fourth made an obscene comment about George Floyd. Meanwhile, others typed racist comments into the Q&A forum. At this point, Councilman Pedro Espinal interjected, asking Igliozzi and the clerk to reemphasize that people should use appropriate language. And he suggested asking the city solicitor whether it’s within the committee’s legal right to end the public portion of the hearing if the comments continued. 

The solicitor replied saying the hearing must happen, but “at some point we should conclude the meeting if this behavior continues.”

Councilors Michael Correia and Nirva LaFortune also chimed in to express their discomfort with the comments being made. 

“I think with everything that’s been happening throughout our nation and within our communities, this is an awful time to have to deal with this,” LaFortune said. “I really don’t want to hear the N-word again.” 

Igliozzi acknowledged the hate speech, and said the clerk would immediately mute anyone who used inappropriate language. “On the other end, I know there’s probably numerous people over here who’ve been waiting and want to speak in an appropriate manner, and I want to make sure I give them that opportunity,” Igliozzi replied. 

The next commenter began by talk, however, referenced hookers and cocaine, and was quickly muted. 

Another councilor, David Salvatore, jumped in to suggest the chairman end the meeting and consult with the governor and Department of Health about holding the hearing in person instead. But Igliozzi pressed ahead with the public comments. 

Two people offered respectful comments. But the following two did not, one of them using a homophobic slur. 

“Councilchair, with all due respect,” LaFortune jumped in, “we’re giving people a platform to perpetuate hate.”

“Councilwoman, this is not a discourse, this is a public hearing,” Igliozzi replied. “I’m sorry. I recognize your concern. But at this time I’m not going to jeopardize the city’s tax structure, and the ability to get the tax bills out.”

After one last comment, focused on defunding the police department, Igliozzi ended the meeting, saying that there were no other people waiting to speak. As the Zoom call ended, multiple council members were heard trying to interject. After the call, Councilor Kat Kerwin said she was trying to say that there were more people with their hands up. 

Octavia Chavez-Richmond said she and her partner had both raised their hands at the start of the call, but that the “raise hand” function was disabled towards the end of the call, and they were effectively kicked out of the queue waiting to speak.

City Clerk Shawn Selleck confirmed Wednesday that over 40 people had their hands raised at one point.

“I did not remove anyone,” Selleck said via email. “It appears somehow people’s hands were lowered. We do not know who did this, but it seems pretty obvious that this occurred.”

Selleck said the city believes the problem was linked to the Host ID function, which the city used for the first time Tuesday night in order to accommodate up to 500 participants. He said the city will not use this function again, and instead is upgrading the ID used for past public hearings held over Zoom.

For activists who’d hoped to use the hearing as a chance to urge the council to shift money out of the police department and into other social services, the hearing was disappointing.  

“From the start of the call we saw how unprepared they were,” said Charlotte Abotsi. She helped write letters advocating for the city to cut the police department budget, and was encouraging fellow activists to use this hearing as a forum to voice concerns. “College courses are getting Zoom-bombed every day. I cannot believe the city of Providence couldn’t handle this.”

Abotsi said the city should have been able to identify the people making racist comments more quickly. But she added, abruptly ending the meeting meant others who wanted to testify were not able to. 

“These people did this to derail our efforts and the conversation,” about defunding police departments. Abotsi added, “It was just so disappointing for [the city councilors] to intensely advocate for this hearing to be shut down.”

Abotsi said she’s rattled by the racist comments, but she wants the chance to have a public conversation about how the city’s budget is used.

Speaking after the hearing, Igliozzi defended his decision to end the hearing, saying there were no more hands raised in the Zoom call. He said the committee will reschedule the hearing for June 22nd.

“People said after the meeting that those issues were occurring, these technical glitches were occurring, so in an abundance of caution we’re going to call for another public hearing.”

People have a right to speak in a public hearing, Igliozzi stressed, even if their view is controversial or their language is offensive.

“People have said some really rough things to us, right to our face on the mic,” Igliozzi said of past in-person hearings. Now, COVID-19 has forced public hearings online. “The difference here is, with modern technology, it creates anonymity.” 

Igliozzi said rescheduling the hearing will delay the budget process by a couple of weeks. And he said, offensive comments or no, the next hearing will go forward. 

Science and Environment Reporter401-302-1057srudin@thepublicsradio.org Sofie Rudin is the science and environment reporter at The Public’s Radio. She previously worked as producer, editor, and general...