In Providence, advocates of the so-called Community Safety Act have advanced a revised version of the city ordinance they say aims to improve police and community relations.
Advocates, activists and community organizations have worked on the so-called Community Safety Act for more than two years. The proposed ordinance was first drafted following a slew of police shootings across the nation.
Advocates say the purpose of the ordinance is to protect Providence residents against profiling by police. The proposal has faced pushback from local law enforcement since its inception, saying the ordinance is too sweeping, and could hinder police work.
The two sides have been in talks working out a revised document, which was presented during a public hearing Monday night. Despite the changes, Providence Public Safety Commissioner Steven Pare told the city councilors in attendance he still sees issues with the proposed ordinance. Specifically, Pare said he felt the bill could hamper police investigations.
Supporters flooded the council chambers and expressed frustration, saying they felt they’d made enough concessions. 
Shannah Kurland, an attorney who helped draft the ordinance said there are numerous changes. For instance, the bill originally required residents to be notified if they were included the city’s so-called gang database.
“If you’re over 18, then this would allow you to find out, and there is an exception if there is an active investigation – ‘imminent law enforcement action’ is the phrasing,’” said Kurland. “So again we’ve worked with them and we’ve made some changes to try and work with their concerns.”
City police say they use the gang database to help monitor criminal activity. They say notifying people in the gang database would effectively amount to tipping people off who are under investigation. Advocates say the database unfairly targets youth of color in the city.
Another change included allowing police to dictate policy for the use of body cameras, which city police are expected to adopt in the coming months.
“On video recording by police, when it’s their devices, we agreed with a change that the administration wanted, that the standards would be developed in police department policy, versus the standards we laid out,” said Kurland.
The ordinance now includes new language protecting undocumented residents against immigration detainers, a change Kurland said is necessary as Providence touts itself as a “sanctuary city.”
“This is really the best, up to date language that there can be in there,” said Kurland. “And it just clarifies what exactly it is that the city can’t do in terms of complying with ICE for civil warrants.”
Providence police already refuse to hold undocumented residents for immigration detainers without a criminal warrant. Further, profiling and discrimination of any kind is already prohibited under federal law and the city police code of conduct. But advocates say the proposed ordinance would codify more specific definitions, including race, gender, and sexual orientation. Commissioner Pare offered optimistic remarks at the end of his statement to the council.
“I think we could work through some of the concerns for law enforcement and Providence Police, in getting to language that doesn’t tie their hands,” said Pare. No vote was scheduled for the ordinance.

