Iowa City resident Paul Wittau was one of the progressive young voters that fueled Sanders’ surge in 2016. In January of that year, just a few days before the Iowa caucuses, Vermont Public Radio interviewed Wittau at a political rally in Iowa City.“I think the thing that pulled me to Bernie the most is just anytime he spoke it just kind of got me excited, you know?” Wittau said then.
Reached by phone Tuesday morning, Wittau said he was “glad to hear” that Sanders had announced another run in 2020. But while he retains an allegiance to the senator from Vermont, Wittau said he wants to study up on a slate of 2020 Democratic contenders that seems to be growing by the day.
“I’m not ruling anyone out yet. I kind of want to see how things progress a little bit more,” Wittau said.
In early 2016, the choice for progressive Democratic voters like Wittau was a simple one: Sanders was the only candidate calling for "Medicare for All," the only one promising tax hikes on the wealthy to pay for tuition-free public college.
That’s not the case in 2016, according to Norwich University political science professor Ted Kohn.
“It’s not 2016 anymore. And it’s not just that Bernie Sanders isn’t the liberal alternative to Hillary Clinton — back then, he was the only alternative to Hillary Clinton,” Kohn said.
Kohn said Sanders’ status as the lone “anti-establishment outsider” has been subsumed by a roster of compelling Democratic candidates who mostly share his progressive platform.
“Really his candidacy represented something in 2016 that I just don’t think ... it will in 2020,” Kohn said.
Ken Rudin, host of the weekly podcast Political Junkie, said it’s true that Sanders’ platform no longer differentiates him in the way it did two years ago. But he said Sanders does carry one key advantage: “A base of supporters, base of low-dollar contributors that other candidates would kill for, ... could only dream about,” Rudin said.
The question now, according to Rudin, is whether Sanders can hold onto that base, or if it’ll migrate to one of the dozens of contenders expected to enter the field in the coming months.
Matt Dickinson, professor of political science at Middlebury College, said it could be harder for Sanders to hold that base in 2020 than it was in 2016.
“His support was generated as much by opposition to Hillary Clinton as it was support for his relatively unorthodox views,” Dickinson said.
Dickinson said Sanders’ voice, however, may resonate more loudly than the candidates now offering substantially similar messages.
“Do you want somebody who’s just seen the light on the road to Damascus recently?” Dickinson said. “Or somebody who’s been out there proselytizing on these issues for literally all his political life?”
Brent Budowsky, who formerly worked as an aide to several prominent Democratic U.S. senators and House members, said he isn’t convinced candidates’ policy platforms will be the deciding factor in 2020.
Voters in 2016 might have focused on candidates’ competing health care policies or the finer points of their labor agendas, but Budowsky said they’ll likely be pondering a different question in 2020:
“Who can save America from the horrifying ugliness that will happen if Donald Trump is re-elected? That is the dominant view, in my view, of most Democrats that'll be voting in primaries and attending caucuses,” Budowsky said.
And Budowsky said that calculus may well play to Sanders’ strengths.
“He did very well [in 2016] running against Trump in almost every matchup poll,” Budowsky said.
Sanders hopes that this time around, he’ll have a shot at the Trump matchup he missed out on in 2016. And so do his seatmates in Congress — both Sen. Patrick Leahy and Rep. Peter Welch endorsed Sanders for president on Tuesday.
This report comes from the New England News Collaborative: Eight public media companies, including The Public's Radio, coming together to tell the story of a changing region, with support from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.